Top 11 Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers of 2024

Finding dog toys for aggressive chewers can be challenging—until now. Giving your dog something that can withstand its chomping and chewing is ideal. Allowing your pooch to sink their teeth into something desirable (not your shoe or furniture) helps them release energy. 

The quality and safety of tough dog toys are paramount. The last thing pet parents want is to worry about broken teeth or ingested toy parts. For example, while tennis balls make for a fun game of fetch, they are not ideal for chewing. Ensure your dog’s chew toys are safe for their size and jaw power.

We considered dozens of indestructible dog toys for our article and narrowed it down to the top 11. To be included on our list, the toys must be more appealing than other items in your abode, such as shoes or couches. We also looked at textures, scents, sounds, and materials that would stand up to the mighty jaws of aggressive chewers.

Remember, no dog toy is 100 percent indestructible. Always use caution and supervise your dog with any new items. If you see parts flaking off, it’s time to call it quits. Even the toughest materials can eventually wear down under the pressure of a determined dog’s jaw power. 

Our Picks

• Best Overall Aggressive Chewer Dog Toy: Goughnuts Ring Dog Toy
• Best Ball for Tough Chewers: Monster K9 Indestructible Ring Ball 
• Best Indestructible Dog Retrieving Toy: RuffDawg Dawg-Nut
• Best Flavored Power Chew Dog Toy: Nylabone Power Chew Lobster Dog Toy
• Best Big Dog Tough Chewer Rubber Ball: Chuckit! Ultra Rubber Ball Tough Dog Toy
• Best Stick-Style Aggressive Chewer Dog Toy: Benebone Bacon Stick Tough Chew Toy
• Best Dental Dog Toy for Aggressive Chewers: Nylabone Barbell Power Chew
• Best Interactive Aggressive Chewer Dog Toy: Feeko Interactive Tug-of-War Toy
• Best Puppy Toy for Aggressive Chewers: KONG Puppy Natural Rubber Chew Toy
• Best Dog Enrichment Toy for Aggressive Chewers: WOOF Pupsicle Dog Toy
• Best Tire Style Dog Toy four Tough Chewers: KONG Natural Rubber Extreme Tire 

Best Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers: 10 to Consider

When choosing dog toys for your tough chewer, there are a few things to consider:

• Material durability
• Shape and design
• Size appropriateness
• Safety features
• Brand reputation
• Supervision
• Price

We narrowed our list to brands known for producing durable products for dogs who love to chew. Some aggressive chewers are more powerful than others. Use your best judgment when deciding what will work best for your dog.

Supervise your dog while they chew a toy. This allows pet parents to catch any potential issues early on. Signs that the toy is no longer ideal for your dog include loose pieces, chunks are missing, or your dog can destroy the toy in record time.

Pro Tip: While some dog toys for tough chewers may be a bit pricier, they are more cost-effective in the long run since they last longer.

Here are our top 11 tough chewer dog toys.

Best Overall Aggressive Chewer Dog Toy

Our Pick: Goughnuts Ring Dog Toy

Goughnuts touts itself as the ‘world’s safest dog toy’ and guarantees them for life. Each Goughnuts ring is made in the United States using engineered carbon reinforcement to create a natural rubber ring. The ring bounces, floats, and rolls and is made to withstand fetching, chewing, and more. Available in various colors and sizes, each Goughnut product is made with two layers. The outer layer indicates strength, while the inner core is red, a safety feature. If you see red, it’s time to return it for a new Goughnuts rng. 

Highlights

• Made for all life stages.
• Tough rubber material can withstand extreme games and outdoor fun.
• Several colors and sizes for all dogs.
• Easily cleans with warm water.
• The two-layer design features a red inner safety indicator.
• Floats on water if your dog loves to swim or fetch in water.
• Made in the United States.
• Each Goughnut is guaranteed for life.

Things to Consider

• A bit on the pricey side. 
• Always supervise your dog when chewing and watch for the red safety indicator.

Best Ball for Tough Chewers

Our Pick: Monster K9 Indestructible Ring Ball

If your tough chewer loves playing with a ball, meet the Monster K9 Indestructible Ring Ball. Made with a proprietary rubber compound, it is industrial-strength and bite-resistant. Each 5.5-inch ring ball contains no sharp edges that may splinter. It has been lab-tested and comes with a lifetime replacement. Monster K9 Dog Toys have been around since 2016. The company offers black rubber dog toys and touts them as the strongest available. Their natural rubber us food-safe, third-party tested, and CPSIA-approved, which is a children’s toy standard. 

Highlights

• Each ball measures 5.5 inches in length, width, and height for indoor and outdoor use.
• Made from heavy-duty natural rubber for aggressive chewers.
• Made from food-safe, toxin-free natural rubber, so pet parents feel safe. 
• The rubber compound is tear-resistant, chew-resistant, and puncture-resistant.
• Helps cut down on environmental waste since you won’t need to keep purchasing toys.
• Comes with a lifetime replacement guarantee. 

Things to Consider

• It is only available in a solid pattern.
• A bit on the pricey side.

Best Indestructible Dog Retrieving Toy

Our Pick: RuffDawg Dawg-Nut

Dogs just want to have fun, so engage them with the RuffDawg FDA-approved 100% rubber dog toy. Free from phthalates, latex, and BPAs, it is safe and durable for dogs of all sizes. This chew toy washes clean, is weatherproof, and bounces and floats! Take it on the go, for fun at the beach, or just play with it indoors. Since it comes in two sizes, small to extra-large dogs will enjoy this American-made toy for rough chewers.

Highlights

• Made of a springy texture that dogs love to bite into.
• Available in different sizes to accommodate all dogs.
• This eco-friendly toy is completely recyclable.
• Gentle on teeth so pet parents can feel good about choosing this toy.
• Made in the United States.
• The regular size is 3.5” x 3.5” x 1.5”, and the extra-large is 4.5” x 4.5” x 2 inches.

Things to Consider

• Pet parents don’t have a choice of color. 
• This toy does not squeak.

Best Flavored Power Chew Dog Toy

Our Pick: Nylabone Power Chew Lobster Dog Toy

Imagine the joy on your power chewer’s taste buds when they sink their teeth into the filet mignon flavor of this dog toy from Nylabone. Featuring three easy-to-hold chewing ends, the textured toy helps clean your dog’s teeth while they chew. Made from nylon material, this durable lobster-shaped dog toy challenges power chewers of all ages. This chew toy’s taste, texture, and structure will tantalize your dog.

Highlights

• Available in two sizes: Small for up to 25 pounds and XL for up to 50 pounds.
• Filet mignon flavor throughout the toy.
• Three chewing ends with an arched shape for easy holding.
• Unique texture helps work off plaque as your dog chews.
• Extra durable nylon material is built for longevity.
• The red color is easily seen, so pet parents can locate it quickly. 

Things to Consider

• Not made in the USA.
• Pay attention to your dog while in use to ensure safety.

Best Big Dog Tough Chewer Rubber Ball

Our Pick: Chuckit! Ultra Rubber Ball Tough Dog Toy

Get ready to see your dog channel their inner puppy with the Chuckit! high-bouncing ball. Designed for compatibility with the Chuckit! launcher, the bright color gives it extra visibility when playing outdoors. This particular ball is designed for a game of fetch with your aggressive chewer. The extra-thick rubber core makes it perfect for water play since it floats. Choose from several sizes depending on the size of your dog’s mouth. As a guide, the ball should not fit entirely inside your dog’s mouth. Made of rubber that is designed for longevity. Have a blast with this fun, tough chewer rubber ball from Chuckit!

Highlights

• Ideal for a game of fetch in the backyard or water.
• Compatible with the Chuckit! Launcher.
• Available in multiple sizes to accommodate every tough chewer.
• It features a super high bounce for extra fun.
• Bright color makes it highly visible and prevents it from getting lost.
• It can be purchased as a single ball or a two-pack.

Things to Consider

• It is designed for dogs, not children.
• This item is not dishwasher-safe or latex-free.

Best Stick-Style Aggressive Chewer Dog Toy

Our Pick: Benebone Bacon Stick Tough Chew Toy

Real sticks can splinter and cause harm to your dog. Benebone offers a safe, bacon-flavored super chewer stick toy. Made in the USA and designed to last for weeks, Benebone uses real bacon for flavor. The dog-friendly, ergonomic design allows aggressive chewers to get a good grip every time. Watch as your dog gnaws on the stick, which features ridges that scrub away plaque and tartar. Benebone sticks are made of nylon and are available in three sizes for all good dogs.

Highlights

• Made of USA-sourced nylon for long chewing pleasure.
• It satisfies a dog’s innate need to chew. 
• The heavy, durable nature of the Benebone keeps dogs happy. 
• It also doubles as a toy to play fetch.
• This Benebone is made with 100 percent real bacon for flavor.

Things to Consider

• The company admits most dogs chew Benebone ‘into submission’ within a month.
• If larger chunks come off, it’s time to replace the product.
• Benebone should not be consumed. 
• Do not wash Benebone in the dishwasher.

Best Dental Dog Toy for Aggressive Chewers

Our Pick: Nylabone Barbell Power Chew

Get ready to help your aggressive chewer with their need to gnaw and promote dental care. The dental nubs on each Nylabone Barbell Power Chew help with plaque and tartar on your dog’s teeth. Made of nylon and synthetic fabric to stand up to harsh chewing, this Nylabone power chew is infused with an allergen-free peanut butter flavor. When it gets a little dirty, hand wash it in warm, soapy water and rinse clean. Your big dog will appreciate the big flavor and longevity of the Nylabone tough chewer dental toy.

Highlights

• This product is made in the United States.
• This power chew is made for dogs 50 pounds and up. 
• The toy has a hard, plastic feel to it. 
• The peanut butter flavor is allergen-free.
• Each chew is BPA-free.
• Robust chewing ends to keep dogs occupied.

Things to Consider

• This chew toy does not squeak.
• Check on your dog frequently while chewing and replace if worn or damaged.

Best Interactive Aggressive Chewer Dog Toy 

Our Pick: Feeko Interactive Tug-of-War Toy

Looking for a fun way to play tug-of-war with your aggressive chewer? Check out the Feeko Interactive long-lasting dog tug toy. This 15-inch convex design toy is made of real natural rubber. Weighing in at two pounds, the nubs and beef flavor entice dogs to play to their heart’s content. The thinnest part of this chew toy is two inches, which is made for even the most intense chewers. It also makes a great gift for the tough chewer in your life. 

Highlights

• Bright red color can be easily located. 
• Made of safe, natural, durable rubber. 
• Beef flavor and dental nubs on each toy.
• The Feeko toy is eco-friendly and non-toxic.
• It is ideal for medium and large-breed dogs.
• This is a fun toy to play for tug-of-war games with your dog.
• Multiple dogs may play together with this chew toy.

Things to Consider

• It can be too heavy for some dogs.
• A bit heavy to play fetch with.

Best Puppy Toy for Aggressive Chewers

Our Pick: KONG Puppy Natural Rubber Chew Toy

When it comes to tough puppy jaws, look no further than the KONG Puppy Natural Teething Rubber Chew Toy. The unpredictable bounce is ideal for puppies with a lot of energy. The unique, all-natural rubber toy is gentle on gums for beginning to light chewers. Available in blue or pink in four different sizes, pet parents can stuff it with snacks for longer play. This puppy chew toy is made in the USA and is ideal for fetching fun.

Highlights

• Available in four sizes for all puppies.
• It comes in two color choices: pink and blue.
• The KONG Puppy is made of customized natural rubber.
• For longer play, it can be stuffed with snacks, treats, or kibble.
• The stuffed KONG Puppy can be frozen for 4 to 6 hours for extra fun.
• Easy on growing puppies’ gums.
• Made in the USA. 

Things to Consider

• Recommended to use up to nine months old.
• Made from KONG’s softest rubber.

Best Dog Enrichment Toy for Aggressive Chewers

Our Pick: WOOF Pupsicle Dog Toy

Tough chewers, get ready for some licking good fun! The WOOF Pupsicle dog toy features a refillable treat holder for homemade or purchased treats. Each refill provides 20 to 40 minutes of uninterrupted fun for dogs. Pop in the treat, close the toy, and watch your dog enjoy itself. Since the WOOF Pupsicle is made for heavy chewers, pet parents can feel good about giving them a time-consuming toy. Consider making your own refills or purchasing the WOOF Pupscicle Freezer Tray, sold separately.

Highlights

• Available in three sizes to accommodate all types of dogs.
• Intentionally designed slots prevent drool from pooling.
• Weighted design prevents the toy from tipping.
• It opens in the middle for easy filling, cleaning, and reuse.
• Pupsicle refill pops are available. 
• This item is dishwasher safe.
• Made with rubber. 

Things to Consider

• Be sure to order the right size for your dog.
• Only available in one color.

Best Tire Style Dog Toy for Tough Chewers

Our Pick: KONG Natural Rubber Extreme Tire 

Made with all-natural black rubber, the KONG Tire is made for fetch and exercise chew sessions. Made in the USA with globally sourced materials, the extreme tire is designed for determined chewers. It comes in two sizes and can be filled with snacks for extended fun and play. If your dog loves to gnaw on things and enjoys chasing toys, consider the KONG Tire for the ultimate chewing experience.

Highlights

• It is designed to hold Kong Stuff ‘N Treats, other snacks, or pet-safe peanut butter.
• Made by a well-established pet product company.
• The round shape is ideal for tossing and carrying around.
• Made in America.
• It can be used indoors or outdoors.
• The sidewalls are designed to double up and rebound when compressed.
• Made with all-natural black rubber.

Things to Consider

• Always use supervision when dogs are chewing on toys.
• Make sure you purchase the proper size for your dog.

Safety Tips for Tough Chewer Dog Toys

The bottom line is to provide your dog with a fun toy that they are unlikely to chew apart. Keep in mind there are no federal safety standards in place for dog toys. Here are some essential safety tips to keep in mind:

1. Avoid Harmful Ingredients: Look for dog toys free of lead, BPA, and phthalate since they will be in your dog’s mouth. 
2. Purchase from Transparent Companies: Look for aggressive chewer dog toys from manufacturers that hide nothing. Take a look at the company’s website for complete details. 
3. Avoid Inexpensive Rawhides and Chews: The right dog chews can be a great way to entertain your dog, but cheaper chews may break off and cause intestinal blockages or worse. 
4. Choose Durable Materials: Choose toys made of durable materials like natural rubber or nylon. Products containing thin rubber or plush will easily be destroyed. 
5. Supervise Playtime: Even the most durable toys can break down. Watch your dog during chew and playtime.
6. Inspect Toys Often: When your dog isn’t chewing on the toy, look at it. Replace toys that show major signs of wear and tear or have missing pieces. 
7. Consider Your Dog’s Size: Follow the manufacturer’s size and chewing strength instructions. When in doubt, it’s best to size up. 
8. Know Your Dog’s Preferences: If your dog is a persistent chewer, give him a toy designed for his strength and tenacity. 
9. Use Caution with Squeaky Toys: Many tough chewer dog toys do not have a squeaker inside. This is because aggressive chewers can tear into them and swallow the squeaker. 

Rotate Toys if Possible: Like children, dogs get bored with the same toys. Some dogs have favorites, so always give them access to those. Consider rotating toys to keep things fresh and new.