11 Best Cat Toys on Amazon
Published on April 08, 2022
If your cat loves to play, then you probably spend plenty of time buying cat toys to keep them entertained. From kicker toys to chew toys and everything in between, there’s a lot to choose from. Amazon is one of the best places to find your cat’s next toy, but the sheer amount of choice can quickly feel overwhelming.
We’ve checked out the best selling cat toys on Amazon, and have rounded up our top 10 for you to choose from. Select the one you think your cat will love the most, or spoil them with a range of these tried-and-tested options.
Our Top Picks
All featured products are chosen at the discretion of the author. However, Vetstreet may make a small affiliate commission if you click through and make a purchase.
- Best Overall Cat Toy on Amazon: Potaroma Electric Floppy Fish Kicker Toy
- Best Interactive Cat Toy on Amazon: Bentopal Interactive Automatic Cat Toy
- Best Amazon Wire Cat Toy: Cat Dancer 101 Interactive Cat Toy
- Best Monthly Cat Subscription Box: KitNipBox
- Best Cat Chew Toy on Amazon: Legendog Cat Chew Toy
- Best Catnip Toy on Amazon: Petstages Catnip Toy
- Best Kicker Fish Toy on Amazon: OurPets Fish Kicker Cat Toy
- Best Amazon Cat Laser Toy: DOLOEDY Cat Laser Toy
- Best Windmill Cat Toy on Amazon: GBYSU Interactive Windmill Cat Toy
- Best Amazon Cat Feather Toy: MeoHui Retractable Cat Wand Toy
- Best Remote Control Cat Toy on Amazon: HEXBUG Deluxe Nano Remote Control Cat Toy Pack
How We Chose Our Top Amazon Cat Toys
When deciding which cat toys on Amazon would make it into our top 10 list, we considered factors like pricing, durability, and the use of cat-safe materials. We also took into account our own personal experiences as cat owners—some of these toys are well-loved favorites in our cat’s own toy boxes!
For any toys on the list that we don’t have personal experience using, we read the detailed customer reviews for each product to make sure they had a high average rating. We only chose toys with a high number of reviews—most in the thousands.
11 Best Cat Toys on Amazon
Best Overall Cat Toy on Amazon
Our Pick: Potaroma Electric Floppy Fish Kicker Toy
This bestselling fish-shaped kicker toy has cats all over the country going wild for its realistic wriggle and irresistible catnip scent thanks to a refillable pouch. The automatic motion-sensor means this fish starts moving as your cat approaches, while the USB charger means you never have to worry about replacing the batteries.
Highlights
- Available in four fishy shapes
- Chargeable via USB
- Made with cat-safe materials
Things to Consider
- Relatively expensive for a cat toy
Best Interactive Cat Toy on Amazon
Our Pick: Bentopal Interactive Automatic Cat Toy
If you’re looking for something to keep your cat entertained as you make dinner (or sit down with a glass of wine) an interactive cat toy is a solid choice. With twin motors, the Bentopal toy scoots around your floor in unpredictable patterns, trailing a feather toy that most cats can’t resist.
Highlights
- Automatic safety shut off
- Two speed settings
- Rechargeable battery
Things to Consider
- More expensive than most toys
Best Amazon Wire Cat Toy
Our Pick: Cat Dancer 101 Interactive Cat Toy
At first glance this toy might look a bit basic, but once you try it out you won’t be surprised to hear that it’s got over 20,000 reviews from fellow cat owners! The spring steel wire holds a small bundle of cardboard cylinders at one end, which when dangled in front of your cat will have them jumping in the air and performing all kinds of acrobatics.
Highlights
- Incredible value for money
- Made in the USA
- Encourages exercise
Things to Consider
- Cardboard may get chewed
Best Cat Chew Toy on Amazon
Our Pick: Legendog Cat Chew Toy
If your kitten is teething, or your adult cat simply loves to chew, then this five-pack of chewable kicker toys is the answer. Made from a durable cotton linen with durable stitching, your cat can chew and bite this toy to their heart’s content. As an added bonus, this toy is also stuffed with catnip for an extra kick.
Highlights
- Choose from three designs
- Great for independent play
- Cute design
Things to Consider
- Catnip is not very strong
Best Monthly Cat Subscription Box
Our Pick: KitNipBox
Your cat will purr in delight at the happy cat box arriving every month on her doorstep. KitNipBox offers four different monthly boxes chock full of feline goodies, such as interactive toys; premium North American-grown catnip toys, and wand toys. Every box contains five custom-designed toys and other treats for cats and kittens (including non-food treat substitutes if you choose the Dietary Box option). Whether you have a senior feline or a new kitten, there’s something for everyone in this safety-tested selection of surprises.
Highlights
- Items are designed to stimulate cats and keep them healthy, fit, and happy.
- Each month’s box features a fun theme, like outer space or rock-and-roll, with goodies to match.
- You can order a Dietary Option box containing all toys for cats with sensitive tummies.
- Options for single-cat and multi-cat households.)
Things to Consider
- Fussy cats may not enjoy each month’s selections.
- Some pet parents say the toy quality could be improved.
Best Catnip Toy on Amazon
Our Pick: Petstages Catnip Toy
The cute and compact size of this soft toy makes it perfect for your cat to bat around the house, while the mesh fabric helps to gently clean your cat’s teeth as they play and chew. This toy is stuffed with catnip which will send most cats into an enthusiastic playing frenzy. It also has a subtle crinkle sound when your cat pounces on it. As an added bonus, it’s excellent value for money.
Highlights:
- Choose from a huge range of styles
- Promotes positive chewing
- Perfect for solo play
Things to Consider:
- Not suitable for aggressive chewers
Best Kicker Fish Toy on Amazon
Our Pick: OurPets Fish Kicker Cat Toy
Most cats love kicker toys, especially if they’re filled with catnip! This cute, fish-shaped kicker toy is filled with 100% premium-grade catnip grown in the U.S. This toy encourages plenty of physical exercise as your cat chases it around the house, and the small size means it’s even easy for your cat to pick this up and carry it to their favorite spot.
Highlights
- Well made
- No stuffing—just catnip
- Great value for money
Things to Consider:
- Can’t be refilled
Best Amazon Cat Laser Toy
Our Pick: DOLOEDY Cat Laser Toy
This high-quality laser pen is made from stainless steel and is the perfect way to get your cat excited about pouncing games. This is easy to switch on and unlike many laser toys, you don’t need to keep the button pressed down to activate the laser. Just bear in mind that laser chasing games can leave your cat frustrated if they don’t get to ‘catch’ their prey, so remember to throw your cat a toy to play with as you switch the laser off.
Highlights:
- USB charging
- Long battery life
- Sturdy design
Things to Consider:
- Can be frustrating for cats
Best Windmill Cat Toy on Amazon
Our Pick: GBYSU Interactive Windmill Cat Toy
Stick this windmill toy to any flat surface and enjoy watching your cat become mesmerized by the motion. This toy comes complete with a flashing LED ball which can be placed in one of the transparent containers on either side of the windmill. Fill the other side with catnip, treats, or another toy. The central section has soft spikes which can stimulate your cat to chew and clean their teeth at the same time.
Highlights
- Choose from six colors
- Interactive design
- Sticks to any flat surface
Things to Consider
- May lose suction power over time
Best Amazon Cat Feather Toy
Our Pick: MeoHui Retractable Cat Wand Toy
Many wand toys are actually pretty short, which means there’s a danger of your cat accidentally scratching your hand if they’re particularly enthusiastic. This retractable cat feather toy extends to 38.9 inches, so that’s no longer a problem. It also comes with a range of nine different feather and worm attachments—guaranteed to get your cat’s hunting instinct going.
Highlights:
- Comfortable padded handle
- Includes two spare strings
- Encourages exercise
Things to Consider:
- Some cats may chew the feathers
Best Remote Control Cat Toy on Amazon
Our Pick: HEXBUG Deluxe Nano Remote Control Cat Toy Pack
This multipack contains two HEXBUG nano robot toys, and two robotic mice. One of the mice can be controlled with the included remote control, while the other toys can be left to create their own havoc as they wander around your house. The robot bugs and mouse are great for independent play, while the remote control mouse is great fun to move around as your cat tries to hunt it down.
Highlights:
- Comes with 12 batteries
- Only works on hard surfaces
- Most cats love them
Things to Consider:
- Expensive
Amazon Cat Toy Buying Guide
Finding great cat toys on Amazon is easy, but there are a few things to remember as you browse all those options. Here’s what to consider before you make your purchase.
Consider a product shipped by Amazon. Before you click that ‘Buy Now’ button, it’s worth checking to see if the product is listed as ‘Fulfilled by Amazon.’ This means it’s shipped from one of Amazon’s own distribution centers rather than directly from the seller. Choosing a product that’s delivered by Amazon means you’re more likely to be able to take advantage of your Prime benefits like next day delivery.
Double check the manufacturer. Amazon is a very safe place to buy from, but there are a lot of third-party sellers to sift through. Choosing a product included in a review (like this one!) means you’re able to head straight to the best selling toys that have already been tried and tested by thousands of cat owners. If you want to check out more details about the manufacturer, click on their name in the purchase panel and check out their details.
Read the reviews. Customer reviews are a great way to discover if a toy lives up to the hype of a manufacturer’s description. In addition to checking the overall star rating of a product, scroll down and have a read through some of the reviews from other buyers. Look for mentions that the toy is well made, durable, and that cats love it! You can also read specific reviews, like all one-star reviews if you want to find out the not-so-good points. The Customer questions and answer section also usually contains plenty of useful information.
Amazon Cat Toy FAQs
Still not sure what toy to choose for your cat? We answer some of your most frequently asked questions, right here.
What kind of toys do cats like?
There’s no one toy that’s going to suit all cats—because they’re all unique just like we are! You know your cat best, so if they love stalking and bouncing, then they’ll probably love a kicker toy. If they’re obsessed with fast movements, then a laser toy could be the thing for them. In general, it’s best to make sure your cat has a variety of different toys, and any of the cat toys on Amazon that made our list are a good place to start!
Are catnip toys bad for cats?
No, catnip toys are not bad for cats. In fact most cats adore catnip! But a cat’s response to catnip is genetic, and around 20-30 percent of cats show no response at all to this herb. If your cat isn’t affected by catnip then there’s no point buying them these toys. It’s also worth bearing in mind that kittens don’t react to catnip until they’re around six months old. The scent of catnip also fades over time, so you might decide to keep these toys in a ziploc bag between play sessions.
Are laser toys bad for cats?
Laser toys are not bad for cats, but they should be used with caution. While most cats adore chasing a laser, they can become frustrated if they feel like they’re never technically catching their prey, because they can’t actually touch the laser! It’s best to keep sessions with a laser toy short, around five minutes or so. And just as you finish up, place a plush or kicker toy on the floor, point the laser on it, and allow your cat the reward of catching their prey.
Why do cats get bored with toys?
If your cat has access to the same toy all the time, the novelty and excitement will gradually wear off, and you may notice your cat plays with their toy less and less. Variety really is the spice of life, so make sure your cat has access to a range of different toys. When they’re not in use, place some toys in a drawer or box, and bring them out another day. Your cat will love discovering what they’re going to play with today!
